A response to "Don't judge marines too fast"

As Sandoval mentions in his response, probably it was careless of the female victim to get out of a bar with the four U.S. marines she met for the first time. Even if she was drunk then, she should not have acted hasty. It is not true that she never had a fault.

Although her careless is somewhat argued, the four marines who assaulted her also should be punished rigidly. What they had done to her is much worse than her fault. The rape is guilty. They should have know it was not fair to assult a strange Japanese woman, even though four men and woman. He seems to defend the four in that way, since he used to belog to or now belongs to the U.S. military.

Moreover, as Egan argues in his response, this case of the four has nothing to do with the withdrawal of the U.S. army from Japan. It is responsible for them as men, not as the U.S. marines. In the last paragraph, he no longer has an objective thoughts but just expose his self-conscious of the U.S. military. He seems to boast that the U.S. military has defended the world including Japan.